Governance ratings can reward weak leadership

Masters of Scale

From Masters of Scale, the episode “The “best practices” corrupting business, with Eric Ries and Krista Tippett” ·

Corporate governance ratings can be misleading: according to Eric Ries, highly ranked companies have delivered worse returns than those ranked low.

In an episode of Masters of Scale, recorded at the summit in San Francisco, Eric Ries talks with Krista Tippett about the accepted best practices he questions in the book Incorruptible. One of his examples concerns ratings for corporate governance and ownership governance.

Ries argues that these ratings can be misleading. Companies that receive high ratings for good governance have, according to him, performed worse for shareholders than companies with low ratings. The explanation he gives is that the ratings reflect how responsive companies are to shareholder demands, rather than the ability to create lasting value.

As examples, he mentions Costco and Patagonia, which he describes as strong companies but which would receive low scores under these criteria. He claims that the usual measures can therefore reward weak leadership, weak structures, and weak culture, because they measure adaptation to shareholder wishes instead of the company's long-term health.

What you can take away

Ask yourself what a governance rating actually measures before adapting to it. Early in a company, responsiveness to investors can clash with building something that lasts.

This text retells what is said in the episode of Masters of Scale. The claims are the podcast's own.

About Signal

Bygger listens to podcasts about entrepreneurship and highlights what is worth knowing for founders of early-stage companies.

More signals